In the world of large-diameter steel pipes, the debate between SSAW (Spiral Submerged Arc Welded) and LSAW (Longitudinal Submerged Arc Welded) is more than just about cost-it's about engineering safety, pressure limits, and project longevity.
Choosing the wrong welding process can lead to project delays or, in extreme cases, catastrophic pipeline failure. This guide breaks down the critical differences, especially focusing on the "25mm thickness threshold" that every procurement manager must know.

1. SSAW vs. LSAW: The Core Technical Differences
Understanding the manufacturing principle is the first step in making an informed choice:
- SSAW (Spiral Welded): Think of it like a paper towel roll. A steel strip is twisted into a spiral shape and welded. This allows for continuous production of very large diameters from narrower steel coils.
- LSAW (Straight Seam Welded): Think of it like folding a piece of paper. A single heavy steel plate is pressed into a "U" or "O" shape and welded along a single straight seam. This is known as the UOE or JCOE process.
2. The 25mm Critical Limit: Why 27mm Changes Everything
A common question in the industry is: "Can I use spiral pipe for a 27mm wall thickness?
The short answer is: No. At a thickness of 27mm, LSAW is no longer an option-it is a necessity. Here's why:
- Machine Capability: Most spiral welding machines reach their physical limit at around 25mm. Attempting to "spiral" a 27mm thick plate is like trying to bend a solid steel bar by hand-the equipment simply cannot handle the stress.
- Residual Stress: Bending thick plates into a spiral creates intense tensile stress. In contrast, LSAW uses a "die-pressing" method that results in uniform compressive stress, making it significantly safer for high-pressure environments.
- International Standards: According to API standards, the upper limit for spiral pipe is generally around 25.4mm. Beyond this, obtaining a quality guarantee or insurance for spiral pipes becomes extremely difficult.
3. Comparison Table: At-a-Glance Guide
| Feature | SSAW (Spiral) | LSAW (Straight Seam) | Best Choice? |
| Wall Thickness |
6mm – 25mm |
6mm – 40mm+
|
>25mm: Choose LSAW
|
| Precision |
Average (May be slightly out-of-round)
|
High (Ovality 0.5%)
|
LSAW for easier field welding
|
| Safety/Stress |
Complex spiral stress
|
Uniform linear stress
|
LSAW for high pressure/fatigue
|
| Cost |
10%–20% Cheaper
|
Higher unit price
|
SSAW for low-pressure water |
4. Selection Guide: When to Use Which?
Based on industry consensus and global engineering practices, follow these recommendations:
Choose SSAW (Spiral) If:
- Your wall thickness is 25mm.
- The application is for low-pressure water transport, piling, or mild structural use.
- The budget is tight, and the environment is non-critical.
Choose LSAW (Straight Seam) If:
- Your wall thickness is 26mm (Mandatory requirement).
- The pipeline is for high-pressure oil/gas, subsea, or seismic zones.
- The system experiences dynamic pressure or frequent start-stops (LSAW has 3x higher fatigue resistance).
Conclusion: Balancing Safety and Economy
Technical selection is ultimately about finding the balance between safety and cost. While SSAW offers excellent cost-efficiency for standard projects, the "safety scale" tips decisively toward LSAW once you reach a thickness like 27mm.
For critical infrastructure, LSAW provides the peace of mind that comes with a longer service life, easier onsite alignment, and full compliance with international safety standards
Expert Tip: If your design specifies 1200 x27mm, always require your supplier to provide an "Expansion Inspection Report" and confirm the use of the UOE process to ensure maximum weld integrity.
Contact our engineering team for a professional quote or a technical consultation on your specific pipeline dimensions.
Email:baohui@bhsteelpipe.com




